Lobster Capital

For limited partners · Manager diligence

How to Evaluate a YC-Focused Venture Fund: An LP Diligence Checklist

YC admission is one filter. An LP still has to underwrite the manager making the next decision.

A fund can be right about Y Combinator and still buy the wrong companies at the wrong prices.

YC says it has funded more than 5,000 companies, and it hosts four Demo Days a year.[1] That gives a specialized venture manager a substantial pool to examine. It does not tell an LP which companies that manager can actually invest in, whether its choices improve on simply backing the available cohort, or whether the fund’s economics will reward those choices.

If you’re evaluating a YC-focused venture fund, separate three questions: What could the manager buy? What did it choose to buy? What did it pay? Then test whether the portfolio and the reporting let you assess the answers over time. Here are six diligence questions that turn an appealing ecosystem thesis into a manager-level underwriting exercise.

1. What is the manager’s investable opportunity set?

Ask for a recent batch-by-batch funnel: companies reviewed, founders met, companies pursued, allocations offered, and investments closed. Clarify whether “seen” means a Demo Day presentation, a founder conversation, or an actual chance to invest on acceptable terms.

The most revealing line may be pursued but not won. Which companies did the manager want, and why did an allocation not materialize? A manager who can explain both wins and misses gives you a more credible picture of access than one who shows only portfolio logos. Deal names and founder communications can remain confidential; a dated, anonymized funnel is still useful.

Ask for: One recent batch’s funnel, with definitions for each stage and permissioned examples of pursued-but-lost deals.

2. What decision does the manager make after YC’s decision?

YC’s acceptance is a screening event, not an instruction to buy every company at any price. Ask the GP to articulate its own decision rule. What evidence of customer demand, product adoption, founder insight, or market timing makes a company investable? What would cause it to pass on an impressive founder?

A polished retrospective can make almost any winner look obvious. Request a small sample of contemporaneous investment memos and passes, dated before outcomes were known. Look for hypotheses, contrary evidence, and what the team expected to learn next. Apply the same standard to misses: a fund’s unowned winners can reveal something about its filter, but only if its interest in them was recorded before they broke out.

Ask for: Two dated investment decisions and one dated pass, with identifying details redacted if necessary. What observation would have reversed each decision?

3. Did access translate into a sensible purchase?

Getting into a sought-after round is not the same as buying it well. Ask how the manager weighed the entry valuation, the security purchased, the resulting ownership, and expected dilution against the company’s evidence at the time. A high-growth company can be a poor fund investment if too much success is already reflected in the price.

For a representative deal, have the manager walk through a range of outcomes and the fund’s remaining ownership after plausible follow-on rounds. The purpose is not to ask for a precise exit forecast; it is to see whether the fund’s economics can work under assumptions you can understand and challenge. Also ask for an example of a company the team liked but declined because the terms did not work.

Ask for: A dated investment memo, an ownership-and-dilution sensitivity, and a price- or terms-driven pass.

4. Does the portfolio construction match the thesis?

The fund’s stated filter needs to fit its capital. How many initial positions does it expect? How much capital is reserved for follow-ons? Across how many YC batches does it expect to deploy? What happens if the best opportunities cluster in one batch, or if the manager cannot win the allocations it wants?

Test concentration in more than one direction. A YC-only fund may hold companies across sectors and batches while remaining concentrated in a single sourcing ecosystem. A selective fund may also become unusually dependent on one company or one vintage. Neither fact automatically disqualifies it, but the GP should be able to show the trade-offs rather than calling the portfolio “diversified” without specifying what is diversified.

Ask for: A simple construction model showing initial positions, reserves, batch exposure, and the effect of one large winner or several losses.

5. How will you know whether the manager’s selection worked?

Do not collapse a prior SPV, an older fund, and a young current fund into one track-record headline. Request results by vehicle and vintage, with valuation dates and gross versus net figures identified. Separate distributions received by LPs from the estimated value of investments still held. Ask how significant private holdings are valued and whether any gains came from a priced third-party round, a manager estimate, or an exit.

Then return to the original funnel and memos. Did the manager repeatedly win access to its targets? Did the reasons it wrote down before investing correspond to later evidence? Did promising passes also do well, suggesting the filter is too restrictive? This is not a substitute for realized returns, especially in a young fund. It is a way to distinguish a repeatable process from a selected set of favorable anecdotes.

Ask for: Vehicle-level performance, a cash-versus-unrealized breakdown, valuation policy, and a dated decision log that includes investments, passes, and pursued-but-lost deals.

6. Can the organization support the promise?

A compelling investment thesis still depends on execution and stewardship. Who sources, decides, and monitors investments? Who reviews valuations and conflicts? How are fees, expenses, carry, recycling, and follow-on allocations handled? What reporting will LPs receive, and when? What happens if a key person leaves?

These are standard manager-diligence questions, not a special penalty for a YC specialist. ILPA’s due-diligence questionnaire provides a broader, standardized framework for the questions investors ask managers; use it to go beyond the investment story into alignment, operations, and reporting.[2]

Ask for: The fund documents and reporting examples, a conflicts policy, team responsibilities, and a direct explanation of terms that change LP-level outcomes.

The one-page test

Before taking a YC-focused fund to an investment committee, try to complete this paragraph without borrowing the GP’s slogans:

This manager can access [defined opportunity set]. It selects companies using [documented decision rule], and buys them at [price and ownership discipline]. Its portfolio is built to [construction objective]. We can judge progress using [vehicle-level results and dated decision records]. The main remaining risk is [specific risk we can monitor].

If the only completed phrase is “access to YC,” the diligence is not finished. The LP’s job is to underwrite what the manager does beyond identifying a promising ecosystem—and to keep testing that claim as evidence accumulates.